Letterwell for Publishers and Where to Sell Newsletter Ads Now
November 2026 · Sponsorships
Platform
commission
You keep
$
On a 30% marketplace you'd keep $, that's $ less.
Example matches, an illustration and not real listings
· ·
$
Pick a format, set your audience, see what your rate card is worth
Letterwell for publishers was a free listing for newsletter owners, with an optional $49 verified listing and promotion plans at $19 and $29. Advertisers could message you or buy a fixed package through Instant Booking, and on those bookings Letterwell kept 25% of your price. In November 2026 letterwell.co shows its FAQ pages and a blog but no way to sign up, log in or add a newsletter, so a publisher who wants sponsor revenue has to sell somewhere else.
That leaves a practical question for anyone who listed there or was about to: which route pays you the most for the same send? Below are Letterwell's own publisher terms, what we found when we checked the site, and a worked year of sponsor revenue for one newsletter run through five ways of selling it.
Is Letterwell still active?
We could not find a working way in. The Letterwell publisher FAQ is online and dated April 2026, and it still tells you to click an Add Newsletter button at the top of the site. That button is not there. The navigation is Home, About, Contact and Blog, and the blog posts are general email marketing articles rather than marketplace news. Paved, which competes with Letterwell and so has an interest in saying this, wrote in 2023 that users reported Letterwell had quietly shut down by 2022, after attracting about 400 newsletters with a median audience near 10,000 subscribers.
So treat Letterwell as a reference for how a newsletter ad marketplace can be priced, not as a place to send your media kit. If you still have a Letterwell profile somewhere, assume no advertiser is reading it.
How much did Letterwell charge newsletters?
Listing was free if Letterwell accepted your newsletter, and acceptance needed proof of your subscriber count, open rate and click rate. On top of that the publisher FAQ lists four paid items.
| Letterwell item | Price | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| Free listing | $0 | Profile in the marketplace after review, usually within 24 hours |
| Verified listing | $49 | Verified badge on the profile |
| Pro promotion | $19 | Homepage spotlight and top of search results |
| Premium promotion | $29 | Pro placement plus a mention in the monthly digest |
| Instant Booking | 25% of your price | Fixed package advertisers could buy without negotiating, paid out after the ad ran |
One detail is worth knowing if you are comparing notes with other publishers. The same FAQ answers the cost question twice and gives two numbers. One answer says Instant Bookings carry a 10% platform fee. A few lines later it says they carry 10% for advertisers and 25% for newsletters. The advertiser FAQ confirms the 10% on the buyer side, so the full picture is 10% added for the advertiser and 25% taken from you. On a $1,000 send the advertiser paid $1,100 and you received $750, which means Letterwell kept about 32% of everything the advertiser spent.
Deals agreed through Direct Message were not described as carrying a fee. That is why many publishers used Letterwell as a directory and then invoiced the advertiser themselves. The marketplace was worth something as a source of inbound, much less as a payment rail.
Where can newsletters sell ads now?
Five routes cover most of what a Letterwell publisher would consider. They differ in one thing that matters more than any feature: who finds the advertiser, and what that costs you.
| Route | What you pay | Who finds the advertiser | A $500 send pays you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Letterwell Instant Booking | 25% of each booking | Letterwell marketplace | $375 (no booking path found in November 2026) |
| Paved Marketplace | 30% of each booking, 40% of Ad Network earnings | Paved's advertiser base | $350 |
| Passionfroot | 15% on deals it sources | Passionfroot network, or you | $425 on a sourced deal |
| beehiiv Ad Network | Network offers at an advertiser-set CPM or CPC | beehiiv, for newsletters hosted there | Depends on unique opens, see below |
| Sponsorships | Flat plan, 0% commission | Brands browse your listing and message you | $500 |
The fees above come from each company's published fee page or from our own pages that cite them: Paved's 30% publisher cut, Passionfroot's 15% sourcing fee, and our breakdown of how the beehiiv Ad Network pays on unique opens. On Sponsorships the Starter plan is $24.50 a month billed yearly ($49 month to month) for one format, and the Creator plan is $49.50 a month billed yearly ($99 month to month) for every format, unlimited listings, a deal pipeline and invoices. Brands pay you directly, so your rate card is your payout.
What does a year of sponsor revenue pay on each route?
Take one newsletter and run it through every option. The numbers are illustrative but realistic for a niche business list.
- 12,000 subscribers, a 45% open rate, so about 5,400 unique opens a send.
- One sponsor slot per weekly issue, listed at $300. That is roughly a $56 CPM on opens, normal for a B2B niche.
- Two slots sold a month, 24 a year, so $7,200 in gross bookings if every buyer pays the listed price.
| Route | Platform cost for the year | What you keep from $7,200 |
|---|---|---|
| Letterwell Instant Booking (if it still sold) | $1,800 (25%) | $5,400 |
| Paved Marketplace | $2,160 (30%) | $5,040 |
| Passionfroot, every deal sourced by them | $1,080 (15%) | $6,120 |
| Sponsorships Creator, billed yearly | $594 | $6,606 |
| Sponsorships Starter, billed yearly, newsletter only | $294 | $6,906 |
The beehiiv Ad Network does not fit the same table, because it pays per open instead of per slot. At a $15 CPM on 5,400 unique opens, one network ad pays about $81, so 24 of them pay about $1,944. That money arrives with no selling at all, which is its real advantage, and it is a quarter of what the same slots earn when you sell them yourself.
The break-even is simple. The Creator plan costs $594 a year. A 25% cut costs the same once you sell $2,376, which is eight $300 sends. A 30% cut gets there at $1,980, under seven sends. Below that volume a percentage fee is cheaper, and if a marketplace brings you bookings you would never have found, its fee is paying for something real. The table only says who keeps the money once the bookings exist.
How do you move your Letterwell listing somewhere that sells?
Most of the work you did for Letterwell carries over. The metrics it asked you to prove are the same ones every buyer asks for.
- Pull fresh numbers. Export the last three months of subscriber count, unique open rate and click rate from your email platform. Buyers trust recent data more than a network average, and Letterwell's own pages disagreed on its averages (a 52% open rate in one FAQ, 38% on the homepage).
- Write the reader in one sentence. Job, industry, seniority, region. "Operations leads at US freight brokers" sells a slot; "business professionals" does not.
- Publish a rate card with two or three placements. A primary sponsor slot, a classified line and a dedicated send is the usual set. If you are not sure where to start, our guide to pricing a newsletter sponsorship works from CPM on opens.
- List it where brands are looking. List your newsletter on Sponsorships with the audience, the formats and the price per placement, and if the newsletter runs on beehiiv, Kit or Mailchimp, connect it so the subscriber figure on your profile refreshes itself. Brands on the Brand plan browse, message you and pay you directly.
- Keep the old buyers. If Letterwell ever sent you an advertiser, email them yourself with the new rate card. A returning sponsor is the cheapest booking you will make all year.
Search is the other quiet source of sponsors. Brands looking for a niche audience often find a newsletter through its public archive, so if your issues live on the web, it is worth knowing which of them rank for the topics your advertisers care about. A rank tracker such as Serpstracker will show which archived issues bring in readers, and those are the pages to put your sponsor page link on.
What did Letterwell do well that you should still look for?
Escrow was the part of Letterwell that publishers missed least and advertisers liked most. It held the advertiser's money until the issue went out, which protected you from the occasional buyer who never pays. Without a marketplace in the middle, you get the same protection the way agencies do: a short written agreement, payment before the send for first-time buyers, and an invoice with terms for repeat ones. The deal pipeline and invoice tracking on the Creator plan keep those records in one place.
The second thing it did well was verification. Letterwell made you prove your numbers before you could list. A buyer on any platform is entitled to ask for the same, so keep a screenshot of your last few sends' stats ready to attach to the first reply. Lists that answer that question in the first message close faster.
Frequently asked questions
Is Letterwell free for newsletters?
Listing was free once Letterwell accepted your newsletter. Optional extras were a $49 verified listing and promotion plans at $19 and $29, and Instant Bookings took 25% of your price. In November 2026 letterwell.co showed no sign-up or listing button, so there was no way to use the free listing.
How did Letterwell pay publishers?
For Instant Bookings, Letterwell held the advertiser's payment in escrow and released it to the newsletter after the ad ran as agreed, minus its 25% fee. Deals agreed through Direct Message were paid between the two parties directly, outside Letterwell, with no fee described in the FAQ.
What is the best Letterwell alternative for publishers?
It depends on whether you need demand or margin. Paved and Passionfroot bring advertisers and take 30% and 15% of what they source. Sponsorships charges a flat plan from $24.50 a month billed yearly with 0% commission, so your listed rate is your payout. beehiiv's network suits newsletters hosted there that want passive fill.
How much should a newsletter charge for a sponsored slot?
Most niche newsletters price a primary slot at a CPM on unique opens, often $25 to $75 for B2B audiences and less for broad consumer lists. A list with 5,400 opens at a $56 CPM charges about $300. Raise the rate when slots sell out two months ahead.
If your newsletter used to sit on Letterwell, the fastest way back in front of buyers is a listing with a price on it. Advertisers who are shopping for the same audiences use our guide to booking newsletter ads after Letterwell, and the full fee comparison sits on the Letterwell alternatives page. Plans and prices are on the pricing page.
Get sponsored on your terms
List your audience and rates on a public profile, and keep 100% of every deal. Flat membership, 0% commission, every format in one place.
Get started